Monday, March 21, 2011

Why I am not a Buddhist

Earlier this year, I seriously asked myself whether 2011 would be the year I came out and admitted to myself that I am, actually, a Buddhist. My religious/spiritual beliefs are somewhat confusing, even to me. I’ve always felt somewhat religious, even though I know that it’s all a crock, and I’m pretty much a hardcore rationalist. However, no religion I’ve ever found actually seems to suit me.

I’m a bit pagan, in that I do tend to observe the Celtic seasonal festivals, but that’s more to do with marking the passage of time than anything mystical. I’ve messed around with various occult systems, and have found them to be, on occasion, a good way to deal with psychological issues and personal development. (I don’t, for example, believe that casting spells can have any effect; on the other hand, making talismans in a ritual fashion can concentrate the mind wonderfully and help you to focus on the problem you’re trying to address.) I’m definitely not a believer in “big church” religion, and I’m totally opposed to following religious laws that can’t be justified in a modern context, no matter how sensible they were when first conceived.

Since I was about 13, though, I’ve had a fascination with Buddhism, particularly Zen. What I liked most about it was that it was much more about understanding your own mind and learning to live in the world than anything I normally think of as a religion. The Dalai Lama couldn’t be much more different to the Pope – he’s always talking about compassion, kindness, and understanding, not calling down damnation on those who doesn’t follow some archaic teachings, or who follow them in a slightly different way.

Earlier this year, I went to an Open Day at one of our local Buddhist temples. (The Chinese one, not the Thai one in the picture above.). As always, I was struck by the peace and tranquility, and by the friendliness of everyone, priests and visitors alike. After wandering around for a while, I figured that maybe after thirty years, I should just stop wavering and try being a practicing Buddhist. So of course, I wavered. I loaded myself up with all the free literature I could find, and decided to read a bit more before committing myself. After all, I know plenty about Buddhism, but very little about what it means to be a Buddhist.

Two months later, I’ve decided it’s not for me after all. Of all the religions I’ve flirted with, Buddhism’s still the one I feel most comfortable with, but I wouldn’t be honest with myself if I said it was something I can actually accept. Here’s why.

  • Belief in authority: many Buddhist teachings rely on the words of past masters. It feels like some old-time school where all you’re required to do is to learn selected quotes from Aristotle or Aquinas and parrot them back unquestioningly. That’s not enough for me. Just because Lama so-and-so said something doesn’t, to my mind, make it true. However, that’s often all you get.
  • Too many myths: traditional Buddhism is full of mythology. There’s a firm belief in ghosts and other supernatural elements. While I love myths and stories, I can’t make myself believe in them. (Strangely, I have very little problem accepting the idea of karma, but deities as literal beings? Not for me.)
  • Belief in parables: a typical Buddhist teaching method is the parable. Someone does something bad and misfortune befalls him; someone else does something good and he is rewarded. Those kind of stories are fine as kids’ fairy tales, but that’s not something I can accept as part of a serious belief system. It’s one thing when they’re presented as allegory (which Christian parables generally are), but not when they’re presented as literal truth.
  • Reliance on lists: the final straw for me was the extensive lists enumerating all sorts of things. I can’t quite put my finger on why, but those annoyed me. For example, one book I had listed the 80 characteristics of a Bodhisattva. They just seemed to me like lists of adjectives, especially when they started repeating themselves (e.g. neat hair, tidy hair, clean hair, well-trimmed hair). That seems to me like one thing: Bodhisattvas look after their hair. What’s the point in making me learn four ways to say the same thing? It just felt, well, childish. And then they started listing clean nails, well-trimmed nails, clean face, clean skin, clean feet, and so on. Okay, okay, I get it! Bodhisattvas have personal hygiene!
    It was the same with various other lists; they didn’t seem to tell me anything, just weird metaphysical categorization of things for no apparent reason. Like lists of postures you can adopt while meditating (sitting, lying, standing, kneeling, walking, etc) or times of day you can meditate (before dawn, at dawn, after dawn, mid-morning, etc), which basically boil down to “you can do this any way you like, any time you like”. It feels like false wisdom – lots of words, signifying nothing.

Now, I’m absolutely not knocking Buddhism. If the world had more practicing Buddhists in it, it would be a much nicer place. I still believe that the Buddhist principles of compassion, duty, and awareness are the way I want to live my life. I just can’t truthfully say that I believe in the religious trappings with which those principles are presented.

I’ll still have my smiling Buddhas by my desk and by my bed, though. Right next to the Ganesha, the mandalas, the Tree of Life, and the Celtic talismans. There’s something in all religions. Just not the religious bit. Not for me, anyway.


Tuesday, March 15, 2011

The Maiya effect

My wife is awesome. Now, if you’ve read much of my stuff, you’ll know I don’t use that word lightly. When I say "awesome", I don’t mean it like “woah, that was an awesome pizza, dude,” or, “remember Thundercats? That was an awesome show!” No, in my lexicon, awesome is reserved for those things that totally take your breath away and leave you absolutely stunned that you’ve been privileged to witness such a thing. Like the images I sometimes see of space (such as this incredible shot from Cassini of Saturn eclipsing the Sun). Like watching a spaceship hurtle into the sky on a column of flame. Things that make me feel small and humble, and at the same time proud to be here to see them.


So, returning to the start of the previous paragraph, my wife is, indeed awesome. I’m not talking about her magnificent cleavage, though that does, indeed take my breath away on a regular basis. And, it seems, that of many other people. Hell, her boobs even have their own Facebook fan club. (Not kidding!) I’m not talking about her artwork, and her fantastic creative vision, though that was what drew us together in the first place.


No, what makes my wife awesome is the effect she has on people, me included. Ever since I’ve known her, I’ve watched her as she inspires people to do amazing things, go beyond their limits and even completely change their lives. And, which is more awesome, she doesn’t even do it deliberately. She doesn’t actually do anything. She just has to be there, and this incredible effect just seems to rub off on people.

Over the last few months, several people have written to her thanking her for what she’s done for them. Some have become artists after meeting her. Some have dealt with depression. In most cases, all Anna’s actually done is to put on an art show and be there, as a friendly, genial host with an incredible smile and a welcoming manner. Sometimes she’s simply looked at someone’s work, costume, or make-up and said something complimentary.

Matt Stephenson in his happy place :)

In my case, she just smiled at me the first time we met, and I was a goner from that moment. Then we had a long transatlantic Skype conversation one night, and I decided to get off my increasingly morose ass, deal with my personal problems and shyness, and impress the hell out of this woman. And I’m a much better and happier person for it. Just one meeting with Anna is all it takes.

Getting ready

In fact, the "Maiya effect" is even more powerful than that. She doesn’t even have to be there in person. It apparently works remotely too, even on complete strangers. When I first encountered her, she had several thousand friends on MySpace, and hundreds more clamoring to join the throng. Quite literally, barely a week went by without someone messaging to her and telling her how they’d been inspired by her to do something. Usually it was something creative, but sometimes they’d tell her how they’d suddenly felt compelled to do something totally crazy, like go travelling, change their job, change their relationship. The only contact she had ever had with them was usually adding them to her friends list, but somehow just that ephemeral etheric contact was enough.

I don’t know how she does it. You can call it charisma, call it magic, call it what you will. All I know is that whatever Anna does, it’s amazing, and I’m proud and happy that when she changed my life, she brought me into hers.